The Toronto Maple Leafs (23-13-2) will face off against the New York Islanders (14-17-7) at UBS Arena on Thursday night in what promises to be an intriguing Eastern Conference matchup.

Fresh off a 3-1 victory over these same Islanders, the Maple Leafs enter the contest led by the red-hot Mitch Marner, who has recorded at least one point in nine consecutive games.

The Islanders, currently second-to-last in the Metropolitan Division with 35 points, are looking to bounce back after dropping five of their last seven games.

While Toronto boasts a potent offense averaging 3.11 goals per game, New York's struggles are highlighted by their league-worst power play conversion rate and a concerning 3.18 goals against average.

The teams have split their previous two meetings this season, with the Islanders claiming a 6-3 victory on December 21st before Toronto's recent 3-1 win.

As these Atlantic and Metropolitan Division rivals prepare to clash at UBS Arena, both teams' recent form and historical matchup data suggest an compelling battle lies ahead.

New York Islanders vs. Toronto Maple Leafs: who will win?

For tonight's New York Islanders vs Toronto Maple Leafs matchup, our predictive model gives the Leafs a 56% chance of defeating the Isles.

Toronto Maple Leafs: 56% win probability

  • Higher league position (3rd in Eastern Conference vs 13th)
  • Superior goal-scoring ability (118 goals for vs 102)
  • Better win-loss record (23-13 vs 14-17)

New York Islanders: 44% win probability

  • Poor goal differential (-20 compared to Leafs' +12)
  • Lower points total (35 points vs 48 points)
  • Inconsistent recent form (LLWLW with only 14 wins in 38 games)

At Sporting Post, our unique prediction model combines insights from top NHL experts. Instead of sifting through hundreds of expert analyses across the web, you can rely on our predictions to understand the market's overall sentiment. We scan trusted sources, analyzing predictions, data, and opinions, and our AI assigns a confidence level to each prediction. We then average these levels to produce an 'expert opinion' win probability—reflecting the collective intelligence of the industry's leading NHL experts.

New York Islanders vs. Toronto Maple Leafs odds

New York IslandersToronto Maple Leafs
moneyline-102 (via DraftKings Sportsbook)-115 (via Caesars Sportsbook)

Key stats

  • 1
    The New York Islanders have won 14 out of 38 matches this season.
  • 2
    The Toronto Maple Leafs have won 23 out of 38 matches this season.
  • 3
    With 35 points, the New York Islanders holds the 13th position in the league standings.
  • 4
    Toronto Maple Leafs's 48 points place them 3rd in the rankings.

New York Islanders vs. Toronto Maple Leafs form

New York Islanders
New York Islanders
Latest matches
L
W
L
L
W
Victories
2/5 (40%)
Defeats
3/5 (60%)
Dec 31, 2024
Toronto Maple Leafs3:1New York Islanders
Dec 29, 2024
Pittsburgh Penguins3:6New York Islanders
Dec 29, 2024
Pittsburgh Penguins3:2New York Islanders
Dec 24, 2024
Buffalo Sabres7:1New York Islanders
Dec 22, 2024
Toronto Maple Leafs3:6New York Islanders
Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs
Latest matches
W
L
W
L
L
Victories
2/5 (40%)
Defeats
3/5 (60%)
Dec 31, 2024
New York Islanders1:3Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 29, 2024
Washington Capitals5:2Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 28, 2024
Detroit Red Wings2:5Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 23, 2024
Winnipeg Jets5:2Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 22, 2024
New York Islanders6:3Toronto Maple Leafs

New York Islanders vs. Toronto Maple Leafs head to head

New York Islanders

83%

Toronto Maple Leafs

17%

Dec 31, 2024

Toronto Maple Leafs

3 : 1

New York Islanders

Dec 22, 2024

Toronto Maple Leafs

3 : 6

New York Islanders

Feb 6, 2024

Toronto Maple Leafs

2 : 3

New York Islanders

Jan 12, 2024

New York Islanders

4 : 3

Toronto Maple Leafs

Dec 12, 2023

New York Islanders

4 : 3

Toronto Maple Leafs

Mar 21, 2023

New York Islanders

7 : 2

Toronto Maple Leafs