Eastern Conference leaders Columbus Crew host the unpredictable San Jose Earthquakes in what promises to be a high-scoring MLS showdown this Saturday evening at Lower.com Field.

Despite coming off a narrow 1-0 loss to Inter Miami, Columbus remains the clear favorite against a San Jose side that has hemorrhaged goals recently, including a wild 5-3 defeat to Sporting Kansas City in their last outing.

With both teams showing offensive firepower and defensive vulnerabilities, this clash could easily surpass the over 3.5 goals mark as Diego Rossi looks to add to his team-leading six goals for the Crew.

Columbus Crew vs. SJ Earthquakes prediction: who will win?

For tonight's Columbus Crew vs SJ Earthquakes matchup, our predictive model gives the Crew a 71% chance of defeating the Earthquakes.

Columbus Crew: 71% win probability

  • Excellent defensive record (Only 7 goals conceded in 9 matches)
  • Strong recent form (LWWWD - 10 points from last 5 games)
  • Unbeaten at home (5 wins, 3 draws from 8 home games)

SJ Earthquakes: 29% win probability

  • Poor road performance (Won only 1 away match this season)
  • Defensive vulnerability (Among bottom 5 in goals conceded)
  • Inconsistent scoring (Averaging less than 1 goal per game on the road)

At Sporting Post, our unique prediction model combines insights from top MLS experts to give you a clear edge. Rather than digging through countless opinions, you can rely on our predictions to reflect the broader market sentiment. We scan trusted sources, analyzing expert picks, team data, and betting trends—then our AI assigns a confidence score to each prediction. These scores are averaged to create an 'expert opinion' win probability, offering a data-driven snapshot of what the smartest minds in MLS are thinking.

Columbus Crew vs. SJ Earthquakes odds

Here are the current odds for the MLS matchup between home team Columbus Crew and SJ Earthquakes set for Saturday, April 26.

Columbus CrewSJ EarthquakesDraw
Moneyline-200 (via BetMGM Sportsbook)+525 (via bet365 US)380 ( via FanDuel Sportsbook)

Best MLS sportsbook promos

Start OddsCheckerWidget (lazyOnload)
End OddsCheckerWidget (lazyOnload)

Columbus Crew vs. SJ Earthquakes preview

After a narrow 1-0 defeat to Inter Miami, Eastern Conference leaders Columbus Crew look to bounce back at home against a defensively vulnerable San Jose Earthquakes side that just shipped five goals to Sporting Kansas City.

The Crew have been clinical this season with Diego Rossi leading their attack with six goals, though they'll need to capitalize on the scoring chances they created but couldn't finish against Miami.

San Jose's Bruce Arena has assembled an unpredictable squad capable of both brilliance—evidenced by their 6-1 thrashing of DC United—and collapse, having conceded seven goals in their last two defeats.

The attacking duo of Cristian Arango and Josef Martínez gives the Earthquakes firepower, with Arango matching Rossi's six-goal tally and Carlos Espinoza providing exceptional service with six assists this campaign.

Recent history between these MLS veterans points to a high-scoring affair, with San Jose creating seven big chances and firing 23 shots in their last outing despite the defensive collapse.

Key stats

  • 1
    Columbus Crew sits 4th in the Eastern Conference with 18 points from 9 matches, boasting a strong record of 5 wins, 3 draws and just 1 loss
  • 2
    The Crew's recent form (LWWWD) shows they're finding consistency with 10 points from their last 5 matches
  • 3
    Columbus maintains a positive goal differential (+5) with 12 goals scored and only 7 conceded through 9 matches
  • 4
    The Crew has gone unbeaten in 4 of their last 5 matches, suggesting solid value on the Draw No Bet or Asian Handicap markets

Columbus Crew vs. SJ Earthquakes form

Columbus Crew
Columbus Crew
Latest matches
L
W
W
W
D
Victories
3/5 (60%)
Draws
1/5 (20%)
Defeats
1/5 (20%)
Apr 19, 2025
Inter Miami1:0Columbus Crew
Apr 13, 2025
St. Louis City1:2Columbus Crew
Apr 5, 2025
Impact1:2Columbus Crew
Mar 29, 2025
D.C. United 1:2Columbus Crew
Mar 22, 2025
New York City0:0Columbus Crew
SJ Earthquakes
SJ Earthquakes
Latest matches
L
L
W
D
L
Victories
1/5 (20%)
Draws
1/5 (20%)
Defeats
3/5 (60%)
Apr 20, 2025
Sporting KC5:3SJ Earthquakes
Apr 13, 2025
Los Angeles FC2:1SJ Earthquakes
Apr 6, 2025
D.C. United 1:6SJ Earthquakes
Mar 30, 2025
Seattle Sounders FC1:1SJ Earthquakes
Mar 22, 2025
Charlotte4:1SJ Earthquakes

Columbus Crew vs. SJ Earthquakes head to head

Columbus Crew

50%

SJ Earthquakes

50%

Mar 5, 2022

SJ Earthquakes

3 : 3

Columbus Crew

Aug 4, 2019

SJ Earthquakes

1 : 1

Columbus Crew

Apr 28, 2018

Columbus Crew

2 : 1

SJ Earthquakes

Aug 6, 2017

SJ Earthquakes

2 : 1

Columbus Crew

Aug 27, 2016

Columbus Crew

2 : 0

SJ Earthquakes

May 17, 2015

SJ Earthquakes

2 : 0

Columbus Crew

Betting on the MLS?

Sporting Post is your go-to source for MLS betting. We offer expert MLS predictions, top picks, and up-to-date MLS odds. Our in-depth game analysis and real-time insights help you place smarter bets with confidence. We also review and test the best online sportsbooks, betting apps, and the best betting sites. Check out our top-rated MLS betting sites and soccer betting apps to find the best options for secure, reliable wagering.